Hours after Ukraine dropped Kerch bridge span, Pentagon called deep strikes “spectacle,” but Berlin and London pushed back

Ukraine’s strikes deep into Russia have not helped end the war or slow Russia’s advance, US Under Secretary of War for Policy Elbridge Colby told the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters, according to remarks the Department of War published on 17 November. The meeting’s British and German co-chairs disagreed at a joint press conference that evening, which NATO streamed.
The split came hours after Ukraine brought down the road span of Russia’s Kerch bridge. It also came two days before US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and Chinese President Xi Jinping meet in Shenzhen, a summit China’s Foreign Ministry announced for 19 November. Washington has already pressed Kyiv over refinery strikes this fall. This time, Colby argued for restraint in the same speech in which he said Europe had taken “primary responsibility for Ukraine’s defense.”
The Pentagon wants support aimed at the front line
Colby also called Ukrainian strikes on the objects inside Russia “the spectacle of deep strikes designed to incur pain on the Russian population,” and added that “in our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war.” Hits on targets like the retailer Wildberries have probably “hardened the Russian public’s resolve,” in his view, and Moscow may hold the advantage in a long-range duel.
The Pentagon instead wants allied support focused on the front line and mid-range strikes. At the same time, the under secretary said Ukraine should not be made to fight “with its hands tied behind its back,” and that “strikes that target Russia’s warmaking machinery can also help contribute to slowing Russia’s advance on the front lines.”
Streeting and Khmara: Kyiv decides how to fight
Asked by the BBC about Colby’s criticism, UK Defense Secretary Wes Streeting said that “it’s not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war.” Deep strikes, he added, have “helped to degrade Putin’s war machine, buying time and saving lives.”
Ukrainian Defense Minister Evgeniy Khmara said Ukraine has “the right to retaliate.” Russia has struck Ukraine’s bridges across the Dnipro 12 times since 1 October, he said, while Ukraine planned one strike on the Kerch bridge. “For each strike they’re hitting our territory we’ll retaliate twofold, tenfold,” he said, adding that Kyiv plans to scale up its deep-strike capacity threefold next year.
Rutte sidesteps Colby, Pistorius calls the criticism stupid
Before the meeting opened, NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte was asked about the Kerch bridge strike. He told reporters that Ukraine’s defense “means also hitting out at logistical nodes, that’s unavoidable.” He said it remained to be seen what exactly happened, but that judging by the media footage, “it seems that they were successful.”
At the press conference, Reuters asked whether he shared Colby’s position. Rutte did not name Colby, but he said allies agree that disabling “Russia’s war machine” is “necessary,” NATO’s transcript shows.
German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius then said he agreed with Rutte, Khmara, and Streeting. Criticizing strikes on “strategic military and military-use targets” in Russia is “quite a stupid thing,” he said. Allies should instead talk about Russia’s “terroristic strikes every night and every day” on Ukraine’s energy, water, and heat.







