Vue lecture

A Sympathetic Defendant and Well-Crafted Defense Dominated Clancy Trial

The defense lawyer for Lindsay Clancy showed empathy for his client in showcasing her mental health problems. That may have made all the difference.

© Joseph Prezioso/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyer, Kevin Reddington, after leaving the courthouse this week.
  •  

Will Lindsay Clancy Be Retried? The Decision Now Facing Prosecutor Timothy Cruz.

After a mistrial, Timothy Cruz must decide whether to retry Lindsay Clancy on first-degree murder charges, downgrade the charges or drop the case.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Timothy Cruz, the Plymouth County district attorney, at the conclusion of Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial at the Plymouth County Superior Court in Plymouth, Mass., on Friday.
  •  

In Complex Cases Like Lindsay Clancy’s, a Unanimous Verdict Can Be Hard to Reach

Hung juries are not common, but the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy was emotionally wrenching and uniquely complicated.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Judge William Sullivan addressing the jury during deliberations on Friday in Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial in Plymouth, Mass.
  •  

What Does a Mistrial Mean for Lindsay Clancy?

Ms. Clancy still faces murder charges for killing her three children. She is likely to remain in a hospital, and prosecutors may decide to retry her.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Kevin Reddington, Ms. Clancy’s lawyer, said that he expected the district attorney to try her for first-degree murder again.
  •  

In a Last-Ditch Effort, Clancy Lawyer Takes His Case to a Higher Court

In an attempt to fend off a mistrial, Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer convinced the trial judge to give him an hour to craft an appeal to a higher court.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Kevin Reddington, Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer, arguing in court on Friday in Plymouth, Mass.
  •  

How to Define the ‘Reasonable’ in Reasonable Doubt

“Beyond a reasonable doubt” is the highest burden of proof within the American legal system. Still, there is some wiggle room.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Lindsay Clancy with her lawyer Kevin Reddington look toward jurors as Judge Sullivan instructs them to continue deliberations on Friday.
  •  

Lindsay Clancy’s Lawyer Wants a Juror Removed. The Bar Will Be High.

Judges approach complaints about jurors with caution, mindful that in the event of a conviction, a removal could be grounds for an appeal.

© Rodrique Ngowi/Associated Press

The exterior of Plymouth County Trial Court building in Plymouth, Mass., where jurors have been deliberating in the Lindsay Clancy trial.
  •  

Clancy Trial Verdict May Hinge on a Single Holdout Juror

The jury has been deadlocked since at least Tuesday on whether to hold Lindsay Clancy legally responsible for the strangling deaths of her three children.

© CJ Gunther/Getty Images

Lindsay Clancy’s lead defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, said one member of the jury was refusing to “listen to the law" and asked the judge to remove the juror from the trial.
  •  

Clancy Trial Verdict May Hinge on a Single Holdout Juror

The jury has been deadlocked since at least Tuesday on whether to hold Lindsay Clancy legally responsible for the strangling deaths of her three children.

© CJ Gunther/Getty Images

Lindsay Clancy’s lead defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, said one member of the jury was refusing to “listen to the law" and asked the judge remove the juror from the trial.
  •  

Lawyer’s Attempt to Oust a Holdout Juror Threw Clancy Case Into Disarray

The five-week trial looked set to end on Thursday, until the jury sent a note saying that one of them refused to recognize the proper definition of reasonable doubt.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Judge William Sullivan during deliberations of the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy on Thursday in Plymouth County Superior Court in Plymouth, Mass.
  •  

Can the Lindsay Clancy Jury Break Its Deadlock?

In general, juries that have repeatedly reported an impasse are unlikely to reach consensus. But sometimes, those asked by a judge to try harder do return a verdict.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Lindsay Clancy is charged with first-degree murder in the strangling deaths of her three young children.
  •  

Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial: Jury Deliberations Wrap for the Day

Jurors spent about seven hours discussing the high-profile case on Monday, after about 10 hours last week.

© Pool photo by Greg Derr

Lindsay Clancy watched jurors on Friday as they entered the courtroom for deliberations in Plymouth, Mass.
  •  

$42 Million Abu Ghraib Jury Verdict Is Overturned on Appeal

A Fourth Circuit panel ordered the case to be dismissed, citing a new Supreme Court ruling limiting the ability of foreign citizens to sue in U.S. court.

© Andrea Bruce for The New York Times

The Abu Ghraib prison, years after it returned to Iraqi control.
  •  
❌